1. Shows with Unique and Unconventional Detectives

  • Psych
    For fans of The Mentalist, Psych delivers a perfect blend of humor and crime-solving. The protagonist, Shawn Spencer, uses his keen observational skills to solve cases while pretending to be psychic, creating a lighthearted yet engaging atmosphere.
  • Lie to Me
    Lie to Me features Dr. Cal Lightman, who specializes in micro-expressions to identify lies. His methodical approach to solving crimes echoes Patrick Jane’s skills, making this series a compelling choice among TV shows similar to The Mentalist.

2. Crime Shows with Unique Partnerships

  • White Collar
    In White Collar, Neal Caffrey, a charming con artist, assists the FBI in solving white-collar crimes. His relationship with Agent Peter Burke provides intrigue and suspense, reminiscent of the character dynamics seen in The Mentalist.
  • Bones
    This series pairs forensic anthropologist Dr. Temperance Brennan with FBI Agent Seeley Booth. The blend of scientific analysis and intuitive insights makes Bones a great pick for fans looking for TV shows similar to The Mentalist.

3. Dark Psychological Thrillers with Crime-Solving

  • Lucifer
    Combining crime-solving with supernatural elements, Lucifer features the Devil as a police consultant. His charm and investigative skills are akin to those of Patrick Jane, appealing to viewers who enjoy TV shows similar to The Mentalist.
  • Hannibal
    Hannibal delves into the psychological aspects of crime-solving through the complex relationship between FBI profiler Will Graham and Dr. Hannibal Lecter. This darker series offers a depth that fans of The Mentalist will appreciate.

4. Modern Takes on Sherlock Holmes Mysteries

  • Sherlock
    A contemporary adaptation of Sherlock Holmes, this show features quick wit and brilliant deductions. The character’s unique investigative style is a hallmark that fans of The Mentalist will find familiar and engaging.
  • Elementary
    Set in New York City, Elementary presents Sherlock Holmes alongside Dr. Joan Watson. With intricate cases and a strong character dynamic, it’s an ideal choice for viewers seeking TV shows similar to The Mentalist.